Select dates to see exact prices
Select dates to see exact prices
1 / 51
About Carlisle Inn
Heated all-season swimming pool
Enjoy a relaxing dip in the meticulously maintained outdoor pool or unwind in the hot tub, with complimentary towels and beach chairs provided.
Der Dutchman restaurant partnership
Dine at the adjacent landmark restaurant to experience authentic American comfort food, a massive salad bar, and a unique upstairs gift shop.
Amish-inspired craftsmanship and art
Experience a unique blend of modern luxury and Amish tradition, featuring handcrafted beds, local quilts, and a peaceful, home-like atmosphere.
Spacious rooms with dual vanities
Relax in oversized accommodations featuring a unique layout with two separate sink areas, ideal for families or groups getting ready together.
Direct access to the Legacy Trail
Explore Sarasota via the adjacent paved multi-use trail, perfect for scenic morning runs, leisurely walks, or cycling through the Pinecraft area.
Carlisle Inn is a 4-star hotel featuring Amish-inspired handcrafted furnishings and an on-site Amish restaurant and bakery. The hotel offers a heated outdoor pool and hot tub, along with thoughtful beach amenities for guests. Direct access to the Legacy Trail is available, and spacious executive suites include kitchenettes. Guests can enjoy daily homemade cookies and coffee. The hotel has a review score of 9.8 based on over 5,000 reviews, with activities, experience, and atmosphere highlighted positively by guests.
Rooms
Standard Room, 2 Queen Beds, Accessible
- 1 2 Queen Beds
- Sleeps 5
- 460 sq ft
Standard Room, 2 Queen Beds
- 1 2 Queen Beds
- Sleeps 5
- 450 sq ft
Executive Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed
- 1 1 King Bed and 1 Queen Sofa Bed
- Sleeps 5
- 663 sq ft
Deluxe 2 Queen Beds
- 1 2 Queen Beds
- Sleeps 5
- 398 sq ft
Reviews
Excellent
based on 5,855 ratings from top
sites
This rating is from the trivago Rating Index (tRI), which combines guest ratings from top sites for a trustworthy result.Learn how the tRI works
sites
Review summary
Summarized by AI from 1,000+ reviews
This hotel is a tranquil retreat perfect for families, couples, and sightseers seeking a blend of relaxation and local exploration. It boasts a prime location in the heart of Sarasota's Amish community, offering direct access to the Legacy Trail for walking and biking. The property features a refreshing outdoor swimming pool and hot tub, ideal for unwinding after a day of activities. Guests consistently praise the exceptionally warm and attentive staff, and the complimentary breakfast, featuring fresh waffles and homemade baked goods, is a highlight. For a truly serene experience, consider requesting a room facing the garden.
Rated above average for Sarasota
Guest reviews
Excellent94%
Very good4%
Good1%
Fair1%
Poor0%
Top amenities
- WiFi in lobby
- WiFi in rooms
- Pool
- Spa
- Parking
- A/C
- Restaurant
- Gym
All amenities
Property amenities
- Business center
- Café
- Arcade/Video games
- Express check-in/check-out
Wellness
- Massage
- Hot tub
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible
- Accessible parking
Room amenities
- Fireplace
- Shower
- Ironing board
- Television
Sports facilities
- Bike rental
- Golf course
- Fitness
- Hiking trail
Hotel characteristics
- Family friendly
For children
- Kid meals
Location
3727 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, 34232, USADirect access to the Legacy TrailExplore Sarasota via the adjacent paved multi-use trail, perfect for scenic morning runs, leisurely walks, or cycling through the Pinecraft area.
Highlight
Distance from Carlisle Inn
Sarasota Art Museum:3.4 km
Sarasota:5.1 km
Historical Exhibits & Education Center:5.7 km
Sarasota Classic Car Museum:9 km
John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art:9.2 km
Circus Museum - Tibbals Learning Center:9.4 km
Circus Museum & Store:9.5 km
LECOM Park:19.6 km
Braden Castle Ruins:20 km
The Bishop Museum of Science and Nature:20.9 km
Tampa:70.2 km
Orlando International Airport:168.8 km
Explore nearby attractions
Property info
3727 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, 34232, USAFrequently Asked Questions about Carlisle Inn
Is there a pool area at Carlisle Inn?
Yes, Carlisle Inn offers 2 pool areas.
Are pets allowed at Carlisle Inn?
No, Carlisle Inn doesn’t allow pets.
Is parking available at Carlisle Inn?
Yes, Carlisle Inn provides Parking, Accessible parking for guests.
Where is Carlisle Inn located?
Carlisle Inn is located in 3727 Bahia Vista St, 34232, Sarasota, USA.
Which popular attractions are close to Carlisle Inn?
Carlisle Inn Nearby attractions include Sarasota Bradenton International Airport, Sunshine Skyway Bridge.
The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.
Among Top Rated Hotels in Sarasota
- Hyatt Place Sarasota/Bradenton AirportSelect dates to see exact prices
- Siesta Key Palms ResortSelect dates to see exact prices
- Comfort Suites Sarasota-Siesta KeySelect dates to see exact prices
- Magnolia PointeSelect dates to see exact prices
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Sarasota East - I-75 By IhgSelect dates to see exact prices
- Golden Host ResortSelect dates to see exact prices
- voco Sarasota by IHGSelect dates to see exact prices
- Ameniti BaySelect dates to see exact prices
- Hampton Inn & Suites Sarasota/Bradenton-AirportSelect dates to see exact prices
